“Don’t Click It” as a Web UI Choice

Can you really build a great Web site without having the visitor click their mouse button? I think that depends on the goal of the site. Don’t Click It is virtual catnip for those of us who feel compelled to click their mouse. I spent about 4 minutes on this site and although I mentally prepared myself not to click, I accidentally clicked within the voting area, damn it!

I enjoy a good site which makes me rethink my perception of a great user-interface; however I’m not sure we are ready to give up the mouse button just yet. For me, the experience of using mouseover as an alternative to the mouseclick just isn’t acceptable for a multitude of reasons:

1. Accidental Movements – While reading text I often will move the mouse off the page to avoid the distraction when reading. In a mouseover-only interface, this causes the content I’m reading to change. In addition, when moving across these regions the interface is constantly changing. This type of interactivity feels more like a loss of control rather then user-empowerment.
2. External Sites – Mouseover-only interfaces really eliminate the ability to link to external sites from within the Web content.
3. Direct Linking – This interface type doesn’t give the user the ability to share a link location to a particular page or frame within the site.

For me the overall experience was like cotton candy; nice to try but not something I want everyday.